Structural & forensic engineering · Melbourne03 7053 4949
Melbourne · Building assessments

Forensic structural investigation

A forensic structural investigation addresses a defined question about building damage or failure. It brings together documents, site observations, measurements and other relevant evidence to assess possible causes and explain the basis and limits of an engineering opinion.

Discuss this assessment
Is this the right assessment?

When it may help

  • An initial structural inspection has identified a question requiring more detailed analysis.
  • The origin or significance of damage is disputed or not explained by an earlier report.
  • An owner or professional adviser needs a defined engineering question addressed in writing.
  • A damage event needs to be assessed alongside construction details and earlier conditions.
The agreed output

What you receive

  • A response to the defined engineering questions, rather than an unrestricted opinion about all matters.
  • A record of evidence reviewed and relevant observations or measurements.
  • Reasoned analysis that distinguishes established facts, assumptions, opinions and limitations.
  • Recommendations for further evidence, monitoring or a separately scoped remedial-design process where appropriate.

Before booking, confirm whether the engagement includes verbal advice, a written report or a purpose-specific investigation. The proposal should identify the deliverable, intended use and fee.

The agreed work

What can be included

  1. 01

    Define the engineering questions, intended report use and evidence required.

  2. 02

    Review relevant plans, soil reports, photographs, earlier assessments and event or repair records.

  3. 03

    Inspect and document accessible damage under the agreed investigation plan.

  4. 04

    Arrange or recommend further testing or specialist evidence where needed and authorised.

  5. 05

    Examine plausible mechanisms and competing explanations against the available evidence.

  6. 06

    Prepare the agreed report, including observations, reasoning, qualifications and recommendations.

Before the inspection

How to prepare

  • Explain who the report is for and the particular questions it needs to address.
  • Provide complete relevant documents, earlier reports, dated images and a timeline of events.
  • Identify deadlines and any restrictions on site access, testing or sharing documents.
Planning the work

Cost and timing

Detailed document review, site work, analysis, testing and reporting should be identified in the proposal. New questions or evidence can change the investigation scope and need an agreed variation.

Document volume, testing, access and the complexity of the question affect the programme. Provide all known deadlines before a proposal is prepared.

Know the limits

What this assessment does not establish

The level of certainty depends on the quality and completeness of the evidence. Damage can have more than one contributing cause. Some questions may remain unresolved without further investigation. A report for a legal proceeding requires a purpose-specific engagement and review of the applicable requirements.

Outside this assessment

  • A guarantee that an insurer, council, tribunal or court will accept a report or reach a particular outcome.
  • An automatic expert-witness engagement or legal advice.
  • Destructive testing, material sampling or specialist laboratory work unless expressly arranged.
  • Repair design, quantities, cost estimates or construction management unless separately commissioned.
Useful answers

Forensic structural investigation questions

How is this different from a structural inspection?

An initial inspection focuses on an agreed condition or concern. A forensic investigation is a more detailed examination of defined causation questions and may require broader records, testing and analysis.

Can the report be used for an insurance claim?

The purpose must be discussed before engagement. The proposed scope should identify the questions being answered and the intended recipient. No particular insurance outcome or acceptance is promised.

Can an earlier engineering report be reviewed?

A document review can be considered if the relevant records are available. The reviewer should identify which conclusions can be assessed from those documents and which require a site visit or additional evidence.

Does a cause assessment include repair drawings?

Not automatically. Establishing likely causes and designing a repair are different tasks. Any remedial design, specifications or certification should be set out as a separate deliverable.

Start with your property

What have you noticed?

Tell us the suburb, the concern and the decision you need to make. The appropriate scope and reporting can then be discussed.

Request an assessment03 7053 4949Scope, fees and availability confirmed before booking.